The Review Software Standoff – QuickReviewer vs Filestage

In today’s fast-paced digital world, efficient collaboration and project management are crucial for your creative teams. However, communication, workflow or approval-related bottlenecks often delay the delivery of artwork and, in many cases, create a domino effect that impacts the entire project. This is why design professionals and project managers often turn to online proofing tools such as Filestage and QuickReviewer to streamline and remove bottlenecks from creative review and approval processes. These tools cater to creative teams, marketing agencies, and businesses seeking an effective way to manage content review and approval processes.

Choosing the right tool for the job

QuickReviewer and Filestage are mature review and approval platforms offering features designed to simplify the review and approval process. Still, they have distinct differences that can impact your choice. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll explore the key differences between Filestage and QuickReviewer, helping you decide on your creative project management needs.

User Interface and Ease of Use

Filestage: Filestage is known for its user-friendly interface, making it easy for team members and clients to navigate and collaborate seamlessly. The intuitive design allows straightforward uploading, commenting, and version tracking, promoting efficient collaboration. However, the user interface is often overwhelming for new users and clients, making the learning curve a bit steep.

QuickReviewer: QuickReviewer also boasts a user-friendly interface that focuses on simplicity. It offers a straightforward platform for content review and annotation, making it suitable for both creative professionals and clients. 

The simplicity of QuickReviewer makes it the perfect choice for first-timers and occasional users.

Collaboration and Workflow Management

Filestage: Filestage is highly collaborative, enabling team members and clients to provide feedback directly on files. It offers a structured workflow with review, approval, and completion stages. Users can create custom review workflows, assign tasks, and set deadlines to streamline the process.

QuickReviewer: QuickReviewer simplifies collaboration with a user-friendly platform for commenting and annotating files, along with the capability to assign tasks or deadlines for your team. 

Both software platforms fared equally on the collaboration front.

File Types and Compatibility

Filestage: Filestage supports a wide range of file formats, including documents, images, videos, and designs. Its versatility makes it suitable for various creative projects, from graphic design to video production.

QuickReviewer: QuickReviewer also supports many file types, including documents, images, videos, designs and live websites. 

QuickReviewer takes the edge here with the fantastic live website review feature! All you have to do is enter the website URL, and boom! QuickReviewer automatically uploads the website, and you can review it like any other creative. Isn’t that COOL?

Integration and Third-Party Apps

Filestage: Filestage offers seamless integration with popular project management and cloud storage tools such as Trello, Slack, Google Drive, and Dropbox. This integration facilitates a smoother workflow by allowing users to sync their content and tasks with other platforms.

QuickReviewer: QuickReviewer provides integration options with popular file storage and collaboration platforms, such as YouTube, Adobe InDesign, Adobe Illustrator, Adobe Photoshop, Adobe Premier, Google Drive, Box, and Dropbox, which suit creative agencies better.

QuickReviewer offers fewer out-of-the-box integrations, but the ones provided are best for creative agencies. Filestage offers more integrations, but these integrations are not focused towards creative agencies and work better with project management teams.

Pricing and Plans

Filestage: Filestage offers a range of pricing plans to accommodate different team sizes and needs. Pricing is tiered, with options for freelancers, small teams, and larger enterprises. The cost varies based on the number of users and features required. The free forever option offers a host of benefits.

QuickReviewer: QuickReviewer also offers tiered pricing plans catering to freelancers, small teams, and businesses. Pricing depends on the number of users and storage requirements. It’s essential to compare the specific features included in each plan when considering cost-effectiveness. 

QuickReviewer offers a lower starting price, while both tools offer a free forever version.

Security and Compliance

Filestage: Filestage takes data security seriously and offers features like data encryption, access controls, and GDPR compliance. This makes it suitable for businesses with stringent security and compliance requirements.

QuickReviewer: QuickReviewer also focuses on data security and compliance, making it suitable for businesses with stringent security and compliance requirements.

Both tools fared equally on the security front.

Customer Support

Filestage: Filestage provides robust customer support, including email and chat support. They also offer comprehensive documentation and resources to help users make the most of the platform.

QuickReviewer: QuickReviewer offers customer support through email and chat and has a comprehensive video and text-based database of resources with answers to most customer queries.

The verdict

Filestage and QuickReviewer are valuable online proofing tools that significantly enhance your creative project management processes. Both platforms were neck-to-neck in our tests, but QuickReviewer had a slight edge due to its simple, easy-to-use interface, creative team-focused integrations, and lower entry cost, making it an ideal choice for creative teams.

We encourage you to use free trials and demos to explore each platform and determine which best suits your creative workflow.

Some other Posts you might be interested in.

5 Tips for Effective Video Feedback and Collaboration

In the modern digital landscape, video content has become an integral part of communication, education, marketing, and entertainment. As the creation and sharing of video content have surged, so needs effective feedback and collaboration tools. Whether you're a...

Schedule a 30min demo